Skip to main content

February 21, 2025

Senate Judiciary advances Trump lawyer for Article III lifetime appointment

Ballotpedia News
Balls and Strikes
Ballotpedia
Ballotpedia
Ballotpedia
+9

Trump nominates personal lawyer to lifetime judgeship, ends ABA vetting

Trump nominated his former criminal defense lawyer to lifetime federal judgeship despite questionable qualifications

Administration ended American Bar Association traditional role in vetting judicial nominees for professional competence

Federalist Society pipeline replaces ABA evaluation with ideological selection prioritizing conservative legal theory

Republican senators confirm Trump judges without thorough background investigation or legal writing review

Many Trump appointees never tried cases, argued appeals, or managed dockets before receiving federal judgeships

Federal courts lose legitimacy when justices deliver predetermined outcomes rather than applying law to facts

Judicial independence erodes when presidents expect policy outcomes from court appointees on specific issues

👨‍⚖️Judicial Review📜Constitutional Law🏛️Government

People, bills, and sources

What you can do

1

Contact your senators at 202-224-3121 to demand thorough vetting of judicial nominees regardless of party

2

Support the Alliance for Justice at afj.org monitoring judicial nominations and defending court independence

3

Join the American Constitution Society at acslaw.org advocating for qualified judges over ideological appointees

4

Contact the Senate Judiciary Committee to demand American Bar Association input on judicial qualifications

5

Monitor judicial nomination hearings and contact senators about unqualified nominees

6

Support organizations defending judicial independence from political pressure and predetermined outcomes