Trump invoked which constitutional amendment to challenge California Prop 50?

Question

Accepted Answer

Trump's challenge invoked the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause, claiming independent commissions dilute voter power by removing state legislatures. This treated legislative control as a constitutional right. Federal courts rejected this argument: Rucho v. COMMON CAUSE (2019) held that states have broad authority to design redistricting procedures, including removing legislatures. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 even required pre-clearance for redistricting changes in covered jurisdictions, prioritizing voter protection over legislative autonomy. Trump's Equal Protection theory contradicted settled precedent protecting independent redistricting as legitimate. His challenge revealed how federalism arguments shift based on politics: conservatives praised state power when blocking federal voting rights enforcement; Trump attacked state power when California limited federal influence. This illustrates how constitutional doctrine adapts to serve political interests rather than neutral legal principles.

Trump invoked which constitutional amendment to challenge California Prop 50?

Explanation

Sources

Related Questions

PRINCIPLE

EXPLORE

RESOURCES